January 2, 2013
-
Peace
As is typical near the end of December, I was frequently bid "Merry Christmas" or "Peace to you and yours" by Christmas cards. I don't know what "peace" is, other than it's something that I
thinkknow I want.***Disclaimer: too long; don't read UNLESS you're a hardcore word nerd (like me).
***As I often do with formidable abstractions, I looked it up. Why forge new ground when the history of humanity and its capacity for language may reveal an instructive meaning? Maybe I can find something that pieces my notions of "peace" together.
The history of peace is tied strongly to its martial meaning: a cessation or void of war. In fact, there's an uncanny resemblance between the Latin "pax" and "pactum," which often ended a war, the vestiges of which we still use today when we make pacts or agreements. Our word "peace" came to English through Old French and reflects French's Latin heritage: "pax" to "pais" (Old French) to "pes" (Anglo-French) to "peace." In modern French the word is "paix."
What I find curious is how the Anglo-French word completely displaced the Old English word, "frith" (transliterated spelling--the final sound was the older letter "eth," which sometimes I think we should bring back to the English alphabet, but I digress). This is a gross oversimplification; but, in the English language (generally), things that are necessary and essential to life and society preserve their Germanic roots. This category includes things like: water, heart, food, love, kin, friends, sight, help, etc. I would think tha
So...in trying to understand "peace," my question becomes--what does "peace" embrace that "frith" does not? and why? Why trade in a perfectly good word for another one if there's not a difference in the meaning.
One explanation is that there is no difference in meanings--one just became more popular than the other, especially considering that the scribes who accompanied good ol' Guillaume after the Conquest were better versed in French and Latin than in the language of the rude Anglisch. It's easy to see how the Frenchier version prevailed. But, I find this explanation boring and lazy--even if very plausible. So, I continued looking.
Building on my basic understanding (and how I've used it), I reasoned that peace is the absence of conflict--but not all conflict. (Mild) Conflict and tension are what make life interesting. And, in wanting "peace," people aren't looking for boredom. Rather, they're searching for a certain, dependable level of relative comfort where they can build a life. Still, that understanding is so abstract to be almost entirely devoid of meaning. So, to the Web I went!
In the search I came across this Website. There, it points out that "frith" is related to the words for "free" and "friend," those two being related by the idea that a friend is one with whom another has a free association. The gist of "frith," according to that page, is a friendly obligation to certain others (primarily: kin, lords/leaders, gods, and guildmembers). These relationship existed in peace, not because of any wartime obligations. And here, mayhaps an instructive--if exaggerated--distinction can be made: where "peace" denotes an absence of compulsion (as in war), "frith" indicates the presence of obligations. There, "peace" seems like the broader word, while "frith," the stronger...and more telling.
This, ironically, incited a profound battle within me. I recently decided that I only felt "at peace" when I was alone--and not just alone, but on the verge of loneliness--so that I wasn't worried with/about others. And when that grievous twinge of emptiness lighted within me, I remembered all my clamorous experiences with friendship and "otherness," and knew that
lonelinessalone-ness is the best I can do. The source of the clamor was my inability to navigate the sea of expectations, obligations, and the like that relationships bring--and the unsettling realization that there is neither map nor GPS to aid the journey. (There may be a variety of compasses, but that's a blog for another day!)Here, there is a need for reconciliation between these peace-pieces. On the one hand, there's the "Latin" sense--the absence of war, strife, and conflict, which is closer to my own sense of "peace." In the other hand rests the Germanic notion of frith--free association without external compulsion. That association, though, I feel robs me of the peace that I want for my life...
Maybe, to live a peaceful life, one merely needs the ability to choose what stressors touch his or her life. In this sense, the hallmark of peace is choice/control. Not subject to the wiles and grapples and powers of an enemy, there is room for security and refuge and solace in the choices you make. Perhaps peace is the simple, internal acceptance of one's external freedom and realizing the ability to flourish there.
"Peace" in that sense isn't helpful if the perpetual source of turmoil comes from within in you--as is the case with me. But, resolution of that dilemma may turn on the difference between being at peace and being at ease...Idk. Id have the time to look it up either.
Do you have peace in your life? How do you know?

Comments (11)
I like word nerds.
I always associated peace with being content but i now disagree with that. I think you can decide to make changes based on not being content and that's a good thing but it has nothing to do with peace. I find myself most at peace when i am alone but i feel guilty for feeling that way.
But no, i have very little peace, I am working on it.
Could be that the meaning of the word "Pax", Peace, transcends all the meanings you have listed.
Why they should say "Rest in Peace" to death People?Requiescat in pace.Pax was a roman Goddess daughter of Jupiter and Justitiae. Smart guys the Romans.The semantic of this word becomes more extended to the psychological individual and not only to the contrary of war 'Bellum).Has something to do with pact, agreement of a conflict.To be peace must be war, like to see the light we need darkness.English is taking his revenge now with the language domination in the world.Pace en..... ''Vrede' Vrede is Dutch for peace. As you see nothing go lost.
Peace
@DogEatDog84 - The older I get, the more choice-oriented contentment seems to me--and the sharper the line between contentment and peace seems to get. And I feel the same way--more "peaceful" when alone, but still guilty because part of me thinks that that that is NOT the way it's supposed to be. Anyway, thanks for reading!
@carlo - That very well could be. I was trying to get at the transcendent definition...but, the process is difficult. Not peaceful at all! There are so many colliding ideas--it's very dangerous in my mind right now.
I will guess that "vrede" is related, and probably very closely, to "frith." And "Vrede zij met u" as well! (I had to look that up--I hope it's right.
)
I received a button for Christmas that says "Talk Nerdy to me" Ha! Anyway I enjoyed your discussion on the derivation of peace. Peace or frith. I think you misinterpret the idea of frith in that the free association with obligations is really a choice to associate instead of the forced connection of relatives by birth or marriage. With that said, it is indeed a choice to have friends or not. When you have a friend the obligation is one of courtesy and kindness but also the freedom to sever the connection (unlike relatives where you can try to deny the association but DNA will not allow it and the early Church was likewise unwilling).
@murisopsis - I need that button! I don't think I really described frith that well. I think the idea is that there were certain obligations/duties that the kin relationship expected--but no one MADE you act on them. There were certainly consequences (being a social outcast, punished, etc.) if you didn't, but embracing those expectations was still a voluntary act...for me, it's all very abstract and I may have done an injustice to the meaning of both "frith" and "peace" in trying to weave them together or find an underlying commonality. I may have been better off acting like those ancient scribes who simply supplanted "frith" with "peace" and avoided the confusion altogether!
Anyway, thanks for stopping by!
We realze we live in peace when we lose it.( like the happiness )
Peace, frith, aman, shanthi, salam! One and the same.
Peace - I am searching for it but it seems to be a lifelong quest. I suspect that before my last breath, I will realize that I have had peace all along, but was unwilling or unable to see it.
@fauquet - Je suis d'accord. Le paix est un tresor qui reste non détecté jusqu'il soit volé.
@ZSA_MD - I don't know...each of those words has thousands of years of history behind it in its own language. To make an analogy: it's like two identical twins who were separated at birth and grew up in different societies--there's certainly a very strong resemblance, but there's significant fine adjustments that have been made in their lives and by the circumstances/culture/people that influenced them.
@christao408 - That's what I think too--and I'm not sure if the final-realization component is a function of choice or too narrow a sense of what "perception" is. Life really should have a handbook.
True, but they remain the same... like the alleles in the DNA. May be separated at birth, but they have the same whorls.
@TutelageOfTheMundane - Oh, but it does come with a handbook!